One of the major design features of OpenACS 5.1.0d1 is the explicit representation of object identity. The reason I say "explicit representation" is because the concept of object identity has been around forever. It is inherent to our problem domain. Consider the example of 3.x style scoping. The 3.x data models use the triple (user_id, group_id, scope) to identify an object. In the 5.1.0d1 data model this object is explicitly represented by a single party_id.

Another good example of this is can be found in the user groups data model. The 3.x user groups data model contains another example of an implied identity. Every mapping between a user and a group could have an arbitrary number of attached values (user_group_member_fields, etc.). In this case it is the pair (group_id, user_id) that implicitly refers to an object (the person's membership in a group). In the 5.1.0d1 data model this object identity is made explicit by adding an integer primary key to the table that maps users to groups.

Coming from a purely relational world, this might seem slightly weird at first. The pair (group_id, user_id) is sufficient to uniquely identify the object in question, so why have the redundant integer primary key? If you take a closer look, it actually isn't quite so redundant. If you want to be able to use the object model's permissioning features, and generic attribute features on a table, you need an integer primary key for that table. This is because you can't really write a data model in oracle that uses more than one way to represent identity.

So, this apparently redundant primary key has saved us the trouble of duplicating the entire generic storage system for the special case of the user_group_map, and has saved us from implementing ad-hoc security instead of just using acs-permissions. This design choice is further validated by the fact that services like journals that weren't previously thought to be generic can in fact be generically applied to membership objects, thereby allowing us to eliminated membership state auditing columns that weren't even capable of fully tracking the history of membership state.

The design choice of explicitly representing object identity with an integer primary key that is derived from a globally unique sequence is the key to eliminating redundant code and replacing it with generic object level services.